//
“Unraveling the Crisis in American Healthcare” (Part 1 of a 3-Part Series)

Citations for Article Entitled

 

Unraveling the Crisis in American Healthcare: 

Part 1 of a 3-Part Series

Joie Meissner, ND   

      Meissner, Joie. “Unraveling the Crisis in American Healthcare: Part 1 of a 3-Part Series” Vital News for Washington NDs.  Spring 2013 Issue. Washington Association of Naturopathic Physicians (WANP). Web 26 Apr. 13        

Click the links below to view this article in context of other publication sites:

Vital News for Washington NDs. Washington Association of Naturopathic Physicians (WANP). http://www.wanpnews.com/2013/04/16/unraveling-the-crisis-in-american-healthcare-part-1-of-a-3-part-series/

Physicians for a National Health Program National http://www.pnhp.org/news/2013/june/unraveling-the-crisis-in-american-healthcare

             Physicians for a National Health Program Western Washington Chapter                                   http://pnhpwesternwashington.org/

Article with Citations

Unraveling the Crisis in American Healthcare:  Part 1 of a 3-Part Series

Joie Meissner, ND

As NDs most of us are sole proprietors or in small group practices where we may feel cut off from the larger healthcare system. Yet what happens in the reform of our larger healthcare system will have an enormous impact not only on our practices and our patients, but also on our friends, families and on our own lives.

Ours is the most expensive healthcare system on earth. We spend billions more on healthcare than other industrialized nations yet we are the only industrialized country in the world that does not provide some type of universal health coverage to its people. No one dies due to lack of healthcare access in other industrialized countries, and yet a study done by Harvard Medical School and Cambridge Health Alliance found that nearly 45,000 deaths occur annually in our country due to lack of healthcare access.  According to this study, there is a 40% increased risk of death in uninsured American adults.[1]

We spent $2.8 trillion in 2012 on healthcare. This is $750 billion or 27% more than the per capita costs of healthcare in other developed countries, yet WHO ranks our healthcare system’s performance 37th in the world.  [2],[3]

Despite its high cost, 50.7 million Americans do not have adequate access to healthcare.[4] Public outcry over the state of healthcare has already led to the attempt at nationwide healthcare reform known as Obama care. The high cost of the multi-payer system is at the heart of our unsustainable healthcare costs, costs that can be predicted to lead to even more dramatic changes in the healthcare system in the years following full implementation of Obama care.

The anticipated healthcare changes will affect all sectors, including naturopathic physicians, their patients and the treatments they often recommend. Understanding the shape that future reforms will likely take and our potential role in these reforms can help our profession and our patients have greater control over our destiny.

In order to understand the reforms necessary to solve our healthcare crisis, we first need to understand that unsustainable costs are occurring due to the lack of governmental and industry price controls and due to the expanded number of insurance plans and carriers, which respectively lead to skyrocketing hospital charges, and pharmaceutical prices as well as and excessive administrative costs in our current system.

Obscene Overpricing

Brill uncovered the fact that hospitals set their fees for goods and services based on hugely inflated “chargemaster” pricing schemes that bear no relationship to costs, but which allow “non-profit” and for-profit hospitals to maintain plush surplus revenue and astronomical executive salaries.

Brill found that drug prices are so inflated under the current healthcare system that if pharmaceutical prices were controlled to the same degree that they are in other developed countries, we would save more than $90 billion annually and $25 billion/year in Medicare/tax payer savings.[5]

The Private Insurance System Jacks Up the Price of Healthcare

Between 25-30% of all US healthcare dollars go to pay for administration.[6]  Because of the substantially higher administrative cost of the private insurance carriers as compared to non-privatized counterparts like Medicare or Medicaid and because of the logistical inefficiency inherent in having thousands of insurance plans and carriers, the private insurance system inevitably jacks up the price of healthcare.

According to healthcare economist Gerald Friedman PhD., the inefficiencies in our healthcare system which lead to its unsustainable price tag are allowed to exist because the prevailing economic view sees the free-market as the remedy to healthcare overspending.  He explains that the for-profit system economic framework that views healthcare spending as waste is why we have problems ensuring that all our citizens have access to healthcare.[7]

The For-Profit System; Cherry Picking and Lemon Dropping

Despite that other economists like Paul Krugman PhD., Nobel Prize winning economist Kenneth Arrow PhD., and Friedman himself would strongly disagree, Friedman asserts that the prevailing economic viewpoint holds that governmental health insurance promotes over-utilization of healthcare which, in turn, promotes wasted spending. He further asserts that this viewpoint leads the insurance carriers to engage in practices that results in lack of coverage for all Americans. He explains that profit in health insurance comes from a practice called ‘cherry picking’ and ‘lemon dropping’ in which insurance providers discourage the sickest patients, who incur 70% of healthcare costs, from being able to obtain insurance while providing membership incentives to the healthiest patients who incur only 10% of these costs.[8]  The profit motive behind the mainstream practice of lemon dropping is the impetus for many of the rules and clauses in insurance policies such as the pre-existing condition clauses that denied many Americans medical insurance coverage.

62% of all American bankruptcies are due to unpaid medical bills; 69% of these were insured at the time.[9] Obama care’s injunction against coverage caps was designed to prevent the growing number of medical bankruptcies.  However, Obama care does not prevent coverage caps from causing health insurance premiums to rise, thus allowing the high numbers of medical bankruptcies to continue.

 Obama Care’s Exchange Benefit Plans Are Underinsurance Plans

Insurance policies sold on the exchanges created by Obama care are only required to have actuarial values (AVs) of 60% (Bronze plan), 70% (Silver plan), 80% (Gold plan), and 90% (Platinum plan). This means that the actual health care expenses that a policy pays, on average, will be 60%, 70% and 80% respectively.[10] For example, the purchaser of a bronze level plan can expect to pay 40% of actual medical bills even after paying the premiums. Due to their lower cost, AVs of 60% and 70% are likely to be the predominant plans chosen and these plans are highly inadequate coverage for any serious illness such as cancer.

Sadly, these sorts of policies allowed under Obama care will continue to result in extensive numbers of American medical bankruptcies and will not prevent insurers from shifting the costs of covering the sickest patients onto enrollees in the form of markedly increased premiums and cost sharing expenses (deductibles, coinsurance and co-pays).

Not everyone who needs healthcare will qualify for healthcare subsidies under Obama care. Although Obama care enacts laws to address the problem of lack of healthcare access, the Congressional Budget Office and Joint Committee on Taxation estimate that at least through 2022, 30 million of the 50.7 million Americans who currently have no insurance will still have no insurance after Obama care has been implemented. Sources project an increased number of Americans will have very inadequate insurance, leaving them bankrupt should they become seriously ill.[11], [12]

Based on the need to maintain profits, the cost of insuring those who need it most will lead insurer’s to inflate overall premiums and cost sharing expenses. Even those who qualify for Obama care’s expanded Medicaid coverage will still have some cost sharing expenses that for them may pose a financial hardship and the increased cost sharing expenses for those who do not qualify for subsidies especially for those with serious illnesses (the lemons) may lead to bankruptcies and/or avoidance of medical care they simply cannot afford.[13]

Obama Care Isn’t Enough

The reasons why additional reforms beyond Obama care are necessary is because Obama care fails to ensure that everyone is adequately covered, that those who are covered can actually afford to use healthcare services, and because Obama care does not end the epidemic of medical bankruptcies or control the bloated costs that are bankrupting the American healthcare system.

To a large extent, Obama care fails to control the unsustainable cost of American healthcare because it fails to use the government’s substantial purchasing power to bargain down prices for drugs and other medical goods and services and it fails to streamline excess administrative cost inherent in the private insurance system but instead it increases both the patient pool and the tax subsidies to the multi-payer system, the system that the prevailing economic paradigm lauds as the free-market solution.[14]   This is because it does not address the basic precept held by prevailing healthcare economists and policy makers, namely the idea that the free-market can remedy all the nation’s healthcare woes.

Healthcare as Commodity or a Right?

Brill and others including healthcare economists like Kenneth Arrow, Paul Krugman and Gerald Friedman maintain that the very nature of healthcare being essential to life itself abrogates its ability to exist as a free-market commodity. They hold that because healthcare itself cannot obey the laws of supply and demand, it cannot be treated like a for-profit commodity. Common sense tells us that when we are having a heart attack, we are not going to be in any position to bargain over the cost of lab tests. Because of this, Brill insists that the healthcare market will always be a ‘seller’s’ market’ with the seller setting the price as far into orbit as our US promissory notes will stretch.[15]

The effects that the traditional “free”-market paradigm will continue to have on our ailing healthcare system are anticipated to lead to another public outcry for more healthcare reform. We are realizing that healthcare is too essential and too expensive to be treated like a commodity. The next outcry will be for something that goes beyond the for-profit-mindset:  It will herald that healthcare is a human right, best supported by the implementation of a single-payer healthcare system.

We are the only industrialized country in the world that does not provide some type of universal health coverage to its people. A universal healthcare system such as single-payer is our long awaited reform that most other developed countries have already implemented.

Movement in the direction of a single-payer healthcare system has begun in our country. Vermont’s version of single-payer legislation was already passed by both houses, and that state is currently applying for a waiver allowable under Obama care so that it can implement a state single-payer system. Most states have single-payer bills and there is a national bill called H.R. 676 that currently has 41 cosponsors.[16]   The effects of the single-payer reform regarding how we practice medicine and how we are reimbursed will be substantial. As physicians we need to understand how we will be affected and also how we can be a part of the single-payer system that is in the future of American healthcare.

Special Thanks to: Sherry Weinberg, MD, Don Bunger, Helen Thorsen CDP, Don Mitchell, MD,  Jim Squire, MD, Marti Schmidt, JD, David McLanahan, MD, Kathleen Myers, DDS, Betty Capehart, Kathleen Randall, MA 

 

Part 2 of this article“Single-Payer: A Universal Plan that Curbs Obscene Costswill discuss single-payer health care reform- what it looks like, how we pay for it and give a brief overview of current legislation.  

 

Part 3 of this article-“How Natural Medicine May Fare in the Universal Single-Payer Plans that Are Currently Being Proposed” will discuss how natural medicine, naturopathic physicians and their patients would be affected by universal single-payer health care plans that have been proposed with special emphasis on single-payer campaigns in Washington State.

 

Works Cited


[1] Cecere, David. “New Study Finds 45,000 Deaths Annually Linked to Lack of Health Coverage.” Harvard Gazette 17 Sept. 2009: n. pag. http://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2009/09/new-study-finds-45000-deaths-annually-linked-to-lack-of-health-coverage/ Web. 14 Apr. 2013.

[2] Brill, Steven. “Bitter Pill; Why Medical Bills Are Killing Us.” Time 181.8 (4 Mar. 2013): 16-55. Print.

[3] World Health Organization. “World Health Organization Assesses the World’s Health Systems.” The World Health Report 2000 – Health systems: Improving performance-Press Release. 21 June 2000: n. pag. http://www.who.int/whr/2000/media_centre/press_release/en/  Web. 14 Apr. 2013.

[4] DeParle, Nancy-Ann. “The Affordable Care Act Helps America’s Uninsured.” The White House Blog. 16 Sept. 2010. http://www.whitehouse.gov/blog/2010/09/16/affordable-care-act-helps-america-s-uninsured Web. 14 Apr. 2013.

[5] Brill, Steven. “Bitter Pill; Why Medical Bills Are Killing Us.” Time 181.8 (4 Mar. 2013): 16-55. Print.

[6] Magnus, Edie. “How the U.S. Measures Up to Canada’s Health Care System.” World Focus 28 Jan. 2009. http://worldfocus.org/blog/2009/01/28/how-the-us-measures-up-to-canadas-health-care-system/3783/Web. 14 Apr. 2013.

[7] Friedman, Gerald Ph.D. “Why Economists Have Been Wrong about Healthcare.” Conference call. 7 Apr. 2013.

[8] Friedman, Gerald Ph.D. “Why Economists Have Been Wrong about Healthcare.” Conference call. 7 Apr. 2013.

[9] Brill, Steven. “Bitter Pill; Why Medical Bills Are Killing Us.” Time 181.8 (4 Mar. 2013): 16-55. Print.

[10] Levitt, Larry and Claxton, Gary. “What the Actuarial Values in the Affordable Care Act Mean”. Focus on Health Reform. Apr. 2011 http://www.kff.org/healthreform/upload/8177.pdf  Web. 14 Apr. 2013.

[11] Gregory, Paul Roderick. “Government Study Finds Obama Care Leaves Thirty Million Uninsured.” Forbes 22 Feb. 2013. http://www.forbes.com/sites/paulroderickgregory/2013/02/22/government-study-finds-obama-care-leaves-thirty-million-uninsured/ Web. 14 Apr. 2013.

[12] DeParle, Nancy-Ann. “The Affordable Care Act Helps America’s Uninsured.” The White House Blog. 16 Sept. 2010. http://www.whitehouse.gov/blog/2010/09/16/affordable-care-act-helps-america-s-uninsured Web. 14 Apr. 2013.

[13] McCanne, Don, MD. “Quantitative Assessment of ACA Underinsurance.” Dr. McCanne’s Quote of the Day. 27 Apr 2012 http://pnhp.org/blog/2012/04/27/quantitative-assessment-of-aca-underinsurance/ Web. 14 Apr. 2013.

[14] Brill, Steven. “Bitter Pill; Why Medical Bills Are Killing Us.” Time 181.8 (4 Mar. 2013): 16-55. Print.

[15] Brill, Steven. “Bitter Pill; Why Medical Bills Are Killing Us.” Time 181.8 (4 Mar. 2013): 16-55. Print.

[16] Library of Congress. “H.R.676 – Expanded & Improved Medicare for All Act-113th Congress (2013-2014)”. LOC-Congress.Gov. http://beta.congress.gov/bill/113th-congress/house-bill/676/cosponsors Web. 14 Apr. 2013.

Advertisements

Discussion

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Advertisements
%d bloggers like this: